Mishra et al. (2023) apply the TPACK framework to ChatGPT to illustrate the framework is relevant to generative AI. Mirsha situate their argument the significance of the TPACK framework in educational technology and the daily work of teachers. Mishra et al. also point out that TPACK has fallen into the canon of educational technology research, and that it’s not engaged with intellectually. Rather education students learn it as part of another theory to memorize. They seek to make TPACK relevant again and encourage educators to questions of generative AI through the lens of this framework. Mirsha et al. provide an overview of the state of generative AI in education pointing out the pitfalls and benefits of using AI in the classroom, while ultimately coming to the conclusion that the educational space is forever changed because it is not a human only space any longer. Generative AI will require that new pedagogies are created to support learning that is inclusive of generative AI. Through the lense of TPACK, educators will have to think beyond the current moment to the long-term ramifications of generative AI in the classroom to assess student learning and prepare them for jobs in a world we cannot yet fully envision. Mishra et al. also point out that assessment will have to change to accommodate the ways learning will change as a result of human/machine partnerships in learning.
While Mishra et al. provide a robust overview of the current state of the TPACK framework in educational literature, they do fall into a pitfall of separating the elements of TPACK apart in order to explain the framework rather than analyzing ChatGPT holistically (Saubern et al., 2020). Mirsha et al. provide relevancy for application of the TPACK framework and try to provide some examples for how teachers can use generative AI in their classrooms to stimulate learning in new ways. These examples are cursory and only show how the focus on the discussion over academic dishonesty is the wrong place to situation the conversation in education around generative AI. Ultimately, the paper is very well organized. The literature review pulls from relevant TPACK literature, always choosing to cite the seminal work over discussions of the seminal work. The framework does not appear to be mischaracterized, but the separation of the parts does not allow for the creative dynamic between knowledge, pedagogy and technology Mishra et al. pointed out in their literature review to be fully explored in their own assessment of how TPACK can apply to generative AI in the classroom – which is also interesting because Mishra is one of the architects of TPACK.
All three facets of my academic identity – doctoral student, writing instructor, and administrator – are very interested in how Generative AI effects the classroom experience. This article opened my eyes to the reality that learning spaces are not human only learning spaces. While technology has always been at the center of my teaching practice, the technology was always mediating the learning. And now, the technology is participating in the learning (and in some ways, it’s a co-learning experience where the AI can learn from the learner, too). I’m very interested in this area as doctoral student. As a writing teacher, I want to teach my students to leverage generative AI so they can be proficient in using it as a tool to leverage their critical thinking to get better jobs. As an administrator, I want to understand the application of generative AI in the classroom to help faculty create learning spaces that don’t penalize and police students while they also navigate how to use generative AI as a learning tool in their own educational journey.
References
Mishra, P., Warr, M., & Islam, R. (2023). TPACK in the age of ChatGPT and generative AI. Journal of Digital Learning in Teacher Education, 39(4), 235-251. https://doi.org/10.1080/21532974.2023.2247480
Saubern, R., Henderson, M., Heinrich, E., & Redmond, P. (2020). TPACK–time to reboot?. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 36(3), 1-9.
Educational Technology Blog 